The family of 18-year-old Nolan Wells and their legal team, led by civil rights attorney Ben Crump, held a press conference on July 30 to appeal for public assistance regarding his mysterious death. Speaking at the National Urban League conference in Nashville, Tennessee, the family expressed deep frustration over a parallel wave of online harassment, conspiracy theories, and false claims that have targeted them since the teenager went missing following a July 4th boat trip to Horn Island, an isolated barrier island in Mississippi.
Wells' body was recovered days after his disappearance, but the circumstances surrounding his death remain unresolved. While Jackson County Sheriff John Ledbetter initially stated that investigators did not suspect foul play, the official investigation remains active. Dissatisfied and citing a lack of confidence in local Mississippi law enforcement, Wells’ family initiated an independent probe. However, as these dual investigations proceed, the family has become the target of online attacks. Crump condemned these actions, calling the harassers "sick, evil people" for targeting Wells' mother, Christine Wonsley, a nurse who has received threatening messages, harassing mail, and negative reviews directed at her and her workplace.
"They are just sick, evil people who would attack this mother and this father for simply saying we want to know what happened to our child," Crump said during the news conference.
The teenager's father, Elmore Wonsley, shared his grief and frustration, questioning the lack of empathy from the public. "A parent can’t grieve when you have people attacking them, attacking their jobs, attacking their character, just attacking them period," he said. "Like, where’s the empathy?"
Crump spoke alongside the families of two other Black teenagers who died under tragic circumstances this year: 18-year-old Daniel Erving, who drowned in a north Texas lake in April, and 18-year-old Tyler Smith, who died from a gunshot wound on July 4 in Lexington, Kentucky.
During the press conference, Crump revealed that the family has acquired the complete audio recording of a distress call placed to Sea Tow from the boat Wells was traveling on. The legal team has hired audio engineering experts to analyze the recording. Additionally, they are consulting with oceanic engineering experts to determine how local tides and weather conditions might have influenced the location where Wells' body was eventually discovered.
The family is also trying to gather more information to assist Dr. Roger Mitchell, the independent medical examiner who performed a second autopsy on Wells. Dr. Mitchell was unable to establish the cause or manner of death. This was partly because he could not examine key parts of Wells' body, such as the throat and larynx, which may have been retained by state officials for further testing.
Attorney Liza Park noted that the legal team has been inundated with over 100 calls a day and urged anyone with information to come forward. Meanwhile, attorney Eric Hertz stated that they are working to secure an agreement with District Attorney Angel Myers McIlrath to jointly review cellphone evidence.
Christine Wonsley has previously raised concerns about her son's phone, noting a suspicious lack of Snapchat history from the day he vanished and discrepancies in the location data she tracked during the search. According to the Sun Herald, subpoenas have been issued to major social media and technology platforms, including Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp, Life360, Snapchat, and TikTok, to retrieve data from Wells' accounts. These subpoenas follow preservation letters sent to Wells' friends, their families, and local officials, warning them not to delete any records because litigation is "reasonably anticipated."
The toxic online environment has also affected Wells' friends and local community members. Ashlee Cole, a chancery court judge whose son was on the boat, deactivated her social media accounts after receiving threats directed at her entire family, including her young children. Her son, Warren Hudson, revealed in an interview that his family received "thousands of death threats," which ultimately forced him to miss Wells' memorial service.
The distress call at the center of the investigation has fueled further speculation. In the recording, the caller reported that the boat was sinking because of a bilge pump issue. A dispatcher subsequently contacted a captain, who reported speaking to the caller's grandfather and stated that the issue had been resolved.
In response to the intense online speculation, the family of Bart Edmiston Jr. has sent a cease-and-desist letter to a social media user who shared their home address, land plats, photos, and employment details. This user had posted videos claiming that Bart Jr. was a suspect, caused Wells' death, or was involved in a cover-up. Denying all allegations, the Edmiston family stated that "none of these things are true" and announced plans to pursue all available legal remedies.
Related Articles
Md. Kazi Bijoy is a dedicated tech enthusiast and content creator with a passion for digital innovation. With years of experience in the tech industry, he specializes in breaking down complex topics into easy-to-understand guides. When he isn’t writing, he explores the latest gadgets and researches emerging trends in the digital world.